FOUR years after plans were submitted for major development of the former Somerton Reservoir, they have been recommended for approval.

The plans would see a mixture of 146 residential properties built on the brownfield site including:

  • 28 three-bed houses
  • three four-storey blocks of flats, with a total of 72 two-bed apartments
  • one block of 44 assisted living units — four two-bed and 40 one-bed — one staff unit and one guest unit with a gym; swimming pool; restaurant; laundry; kitchen; function spaces and communal sitting areas
  • parking would be built into the former reservoir basin

Concerns over the development have been raised by the nearby Cowes Medical Centre who said they would have insufficient capacity, as well as Friends of Northwood Cemetery, Northwood Parish Council and Cowes Town Council.

Isle of Wight County Press: The former Somerton Reservoir from the sky. Picture by Google Maps.The former Somerton Reservoir from the sky. Picture by Google Maps.

One reason the Heartwood Homes scheme has not yet been determined, despite the long timeframe, is an argument over how much affordable housing would be provided.

With abnormal build costs and challenges due to the nature of the site, the development would be unable to provide the council's required 35 per cent affordable housing contribution nor a satisfactory financial one.

Isle of Wight County Press: The proposed blocks of flats at the former Somerton Reservoir. Picture by Debenham Smith Architecture.The proposed blocks of flats at the former Somerton Reservoir. Picture by Debenham Smith Architecture.

A dispute between the council and the applicants over the final market value of the properties reached an impasse so a compromise has been agreed.

In line with national planning policies, the Isle of Wight Council is prepared to allow only ten per cent affordable housing on-site as other specialist accommodation is proposed.

Officers agree with planning agents when they say the proposed design would have a strong impact to grab the eye and would represent a 'dramatic change' from the current street scene.

Isle of Wight County Press: The proposed housing at the former Somerton Reservoir, looking towards the roundabout. Picture by Debenham Smith Architecture.The proposed housing at the former Somerton Reservoir, looking towards the roundabout. Picture by Debenham Smith Architecture.

Officers say the change would not be considered harmful or unacceptable in the wider context of the need to deliver housing and optimise the use of a brownfield site.

  • Read the officers' full report on the application HERE.

The current bungalow at the site on Newport Road, Cowes, would have to be demolished to allow the development to go ahead though, the council said.

The bungalow's owner, however, objected to the scheme, back in 2018, and said no agreement had then been reached to demolish it.

Isle of Wight County Press: Looking at the proposed development for the former Somerton Reservoir from the park and ride. Picture by Debenham Smith Architecture.Looking at the proposed development for the former Somerton Reservoir from the park and ride. Picture by Debenham Smith Architecture.

As a result of the development, minor highways improvements have been recommended to the Somerton Roundabout due to the potential increase in traffic.

The roundabout will reach capacity by next year, even without the additional housing, but the mitigation put forward would combat rush-hour traffic.

If permission were to be granted, following the officers' approval recommendation, 22 conditions would be imposed.

The final decision will be made by the Isle of Wight Council's planning committee on April 26.